UTG+1 is solid reg, UTG is 50vpip fish so not too worried about his hand.
I can't fold a straight here right? I mean UTG+1 could be doing this easily with a flush draw+pair/2pair/set. The reason why I think maybe I could have got away from it is that he's almost never going to be calling the flop with 2pair/set/low flush which pretty much reduces his range to nut FD/nut flush.
Is it fine to just chalk it up as a cooler and move on, or could/should I have folded here?
PokerStars - $0.05 NL - Holdem - 7 players
Hand converted by PokerTracker 3
MP: $5.05
CO: $12.68
BTN: $5.20
SB: $3.00
Hero (BB): $5.00
UTG: $3.56
UTG+1: $8.71
SB posts SB $0.02,
Hero posts BB $0.05
Pre Flop: ($0.07) Hero has 9

8
UTG calls $0.05,
UTG+1 calls $0.05,
fold,
fold,
fold, SB calls $0.03,
Hero checks
Flop: ($0.20, 4 players) J

T

7
SB bets $0.05,
Hero raises to $0.35,
UTG calls $0.35,
UTG+1 calls $0.35,
fold
Turn: ($1.30, 3 players) 4
Hero bets $2.10,
UTG raises to $3.16 and is all-in,
UTG+1 raises to $5.45,
Hero calls $2.50 and is all-in
River: ($13.66, 3 players) J
Hero shows 9

8

(Straight, Jack High) (Pre 41%, Flop 5%, Turn 2%)
UTG+1 shows A

2

(Flush, Ace High) (Pre 35%, Flop 95%, Turn 98%)
UTG shows 5

3

(Flush, Jack High) (Pre 24%, Flop 0%, Turn 0%)
UTG+1 wins $13.09