Would a winning low stakes online player in 2026 crush high stakes in 2005?
Is poker so tough in 2026 that a small-stakes winner would be considered one of the best in the world 20 years ago?
![]()
Volume is why most online players are better than live players.
Over the weekend, I found myself having the age-old debate of whether a winning low-stakes grinder online could beat much bigger games live. I think the debate is settled on that particular point. Anyone sensible in the game, with an understanding of poker strategy, knows that somebody who can beat $11 tournaments online consistently probably would do quite well in $500 or $1,000 MTTs live.
A different wrinkle to the debate happened over the weekend, however, when it was suggested that somebody who beats $11 tournaments online in 2026 would have been an elite player if they could have time-travelled back to 2005.
The best and simultaneously most depressing compliment I ever had was when Dara O'Kearney had praised my improvement as a player working under him by saying that I had a "thought process that would have made me millions in 2003". I was delighted to hear of how much I improved and equally frustrated that the games have gotten much tougher, so a seven-figure career was perhaps not available to me.
What makes online harder?

The poker boom years were the softest time to play poker
Why is it that we say that small-stakes online players would crush much bigger buy-in live games?
There are lots of reasons. One of them is sheer experience. The fact of the matter is, you get way more hands in as an online player, even if you only play one table. Somebody who plays 4, 8, 16, or more tables will have a level of experience that live players never will. The fact of the matter is, I have played more hands than Doyle Brunson ever did in his career because of this. It might even be the case that I may play more hands in a year than he did in his entire life.
Because online poker is so widely available and because multi-tabling is a possibility, it means that low-stakes poker is actually a profitable career path for many people. As a result, they have to improve their game to compete with all the other players with the same idea. Add to that the availability of online training material these days, and it is inevitable that online players who can beat the game have to have a degree of expertise. They need to be well read on the modern poker strategies and have some sort of study routine built into their schedule.
None of this can be said for live poker. It's not possible to play an $11 tournament in live poker. In fact, for many players, the only game they can play is whichever one is available at the time. For that reason, the skill gulf in buy-ins does not scale in the way that it does online. The gap between an $11 grinder and a $500 grinder is massive online, but the same is not true live. A live poker player doesn't have the option of playing an $11 tournament, so the $500 game might be the only tournament they can play.
Likewise, because we can never get a huge amount of volume in live poker, short-term variance influences much more. It's very possible for a bad player to go on a sun run in live tournaments and think they are good at the game. Again, that can't be said in online poker, where it's very possible to get tens of thousands of hands in every month. The bad players will get found out much quicker.
Mental toughness
Mental fortitude is what makes players elite
So this is why online poker is tougher than live poker. There is less impetus to study in live poker and fewer opportunities to increase volume. As such, you see lots of weak amateurs in live poker at buy-ins you would never see them at online.
All of this would suggest that I'm in complete agreement with the suggestion that a winning $11 tournament grinder in 2026 would be an elite player in 2005, but I am not. I have no doubt that a winning low-stakes player parachuted into 2005 games would make much more money than they do now and likely would make a huge amount. But become an elite player? No, I don't think so.
The main reason for this is the mental fortitude that it takes to play at very high stakes. I don't think that's a trait that can be easily taught, if at all. I am very much a winning player in the games that I frequent, but I think the main reason why I could never go professional is because I don't think I could handle a downswing at higher stakes. It gets to a point where it's hard to divorce the money at stake from what it means away from the tables. I don't think I'm alone in this.
Poker is littered with players who are very, very talented but still manage to go broke because of bad money management and game selection issues. At the highest stakes, these leaks get found out much quicker. This is why I think somebody like Doyle Brunson will always be an elite player, even compared to someone who may have played 20 times as many hands as him.
I believe that a winning small stakes player in 2026 would absolutely crush poker if they had a time machine that took them back to 2005, but I don't think that alone would make them elite.
