I'm sorry if my language won't be fine but english is not my first language. In Italy live poker is not common (it's illegal outside the 4 governament run casinos), so I come here to ask this "live poker" related question as I saw there are many threads on this topic in the english speaking section. I don't have much experience in live games, but living close to Austria gave me the possibility to try cheap tournaments in a live poker room (only 3 experience).
My question is: How trusty classical poker tells can be? What can be the possibility to find a player that is aware about tells and fakes them instead just not giving?
As you can realize my experience about tells is very small, my question came as playing a live MTT with cheap buy in I spotted a huge tell by a player that appeared to be a thinking player, it was so huge that I begun to think he read the same book I read and he was acting. For this reason I ignored it and took my decision with this out of the equation. After the game I begun to think I made a mistake in leveling, because I realized that to fake a tell he must have been aware I was able to read them.
What are your experiences about tells?
in the spoiler I wrote the description of the hand as my question is general and not specific to that, and also because it's played badly
.
Spoiler
I was playing a 30€ buy in tournamet at my table were sitting 5 gamblers (one of them was betting on football games while playing), 2 TAGs and me.
I've been dealt AQo in CO my stack was around 50BB two limps before me and I raise up to 6BB 3folds 1call 1fold, the pot is around 15BB the flop is K 4 6 with two spades (I had no spades) oppo is one of the TAGs and it's the first time he limp calls in around 40 hands played his stack is more or less like mine, oppo checks I bet 10BB oppo calls, the pot now is 25BB the turn is Q not spades, oppo checks I check (ok that was very weak), the pot is again 25BB the river is a 9 of spades and oppo moves all in overbetting the pot.
I had some troubles thinking what his limp/call from early position's range could possibly be as it was quite a odd move for him I'd suppose small PP, it was also odd that he pushed all in a set as the only calling hands where flushes. While I was thinking if calling or not he was just gazing upon me, he was exactly like in a picture of Mike Caro's "poker tells" with the caption: "not a threat", the tell was so huge and close to the picture I begun to think it was a false tell, now don't lough please as I told you i had no live experience so tells are something I'm just not used to trust body language.
I decided to fold as I supposed the times he had a set or a flush where more than 35% thinking a possible preflop limp/call range from early position with the information i had. He showed 53o so my read was correct and he was looser than what I supposed.