Skip to forum
Messi/Suarez penalt...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Messi/Suarez penalty

9 Posts
8 Users
1 Reactions
1,746 Views
8runo
Joined: 17.05.2015

Should have been disallowed. Clear encroachment - how can defence defend against it when he is already half way to the ball?

Bah humbug!


Reply
Quote
8 replies
Moderator
SDK1987
Joined: 12.11.2008

It looks like he was already in the box, before Messi take the penalty.
In that case the referee should make the decision that he needed to take the penalty a 2nd time.


Reply
Quote
profimaximus
Joined: 26.05.2010

You should listen commentator from Croatia. Extazy, gloryfiaction, etc. If you asked him, this penalty must count at least as 2 or 3 goals :)


Reply
Quote
Zanardi1
Joined: 04.01.2010

I don't see anything wrong in this picture.


Reply
Quote
UPAY4DINNER
Joined: 28.09.2009

According to the above pic it should clearly stand as Suarez is outside the box as Messi plays the ball.

Legit goal.


Reply
Quote
8runo
Joined: 17.05.2015

Not sure if I'm being levelled here - but you know the D is part of the penalty box? He is clearly inside.....


Reply
Quote
luizfsp
Joined: 14.11.2013

Nothing wrong with ths play imo


Reply
Quote
akifsadeed01
Joined: 27.02.2016

it definitely looks like he's inside the box before messi took the penalty


Reply
Quote
Malendes
Joined: 03.04.2011

As 8runo mentioned he is in the box (the D part), so technically the ref could cancel the penalty and say they have to kick it again. Considering he is only one step inside, I bet the ref didnt notice it, and it really isnt that significantly of an error - I have seen penalties taken where all the players stood and ran inside the box (the outer part forming a D)


Reply
Quote