Updated on 23 Feb 26 by
Barry Carter
Poker Expert

Bad Beat Jackpot disqualified by river card

The rules are the rules, and as such, Doug Polk's Lodge Card Room won't be awarding a $118,000 jackpot to a straight flush vs straight flush hand.





It has been a bad summer for Bad Beat Jackpots. Last month one was disqualified when a dealer folded the hand and now this. 

At Doug Polk's Lodge Card Club two players flopped straight flushes playing PLO, making them eligible for the Bad Beat Jackpot of $118,000. This would have given around $57,200 to the 'loser', $28,600 to the 'winner' and the rest shared among the players in the room at the time. 

However, the river card gave the 'winner' a Royal Flush, making the hand ineligible. 

This is because the Bad Beat Jackpot is only eligible based on the best hands on the flop in PLO at this card room. The king high straight flush was beating the jack high straight flush on the flop, but the Ace of Diamonds on the river meant that the best hand was not a flopped one. 

poker
A Royal Flush on the river is the ultimate bad beat

The reason for this particular rule is that in PLO, so many more cards are in play, which incentivises the players to check it down to make better hands in a Bad Beat Jackpot. So flopped only is the rule at the Lodge.  

It does seem unfair, however, that the players are made to abide by flop only, but the card room does not. Despite a lot of pushback on social media, Polk did not back down stating that the rules were the rules. 

Do you agree with this ruling? Let us know in the comments:


Poker Expert

Barry Carter is the editor of PokerStrategy.com and the co-author of The Mental Game of Poker 1 & 2, Poker Satellite Strategy, PKO Poker Strategy, Endgame Poker Strategy, GTO Poker Simplified, Mystery Bounty Poker Strategy and Beyond GTO. In 2025, he won the Global Poker Awards for Best Book and Twitter Personality of the Year.